| 164. | Leaf-scars deeply concave on upper margin. | Fraxinus
americana, White Ash |
| 164. | Leaf-scars not deeply concave on upper margin (semicircular to shield-shaped). | 165 |
| 165. | Bark soft-scaly; buds generally black; last pair of leaf-scars generally some distance below end of twig (giving a stalked-like appearance to the terminal bud). | Fraxinus
nigra, Black Ash |
| 165. | Bark ridged, not soft-scaly. | 166 |
| 166. | Buds black; trees found only in cultivation. | Fraxinus
excelsior, European Ash |
| 166. | Buds dark brown; trees native. | 167 |
| 167. | Twigs
downy. (Note: F. pennsylvanica is a variable species) |
Fraxinus
pennsylvanica, Red Ash |
| 167. | Twigs
smooth. (Note: F. pennsylvanica is a variable species) |
Fraxinus
pennsylvanica, Green Ash |